Cousin Vinnies NY Pizza Cafe - Friday Harbor (WA)

4 /5 Ryan Wallace: Don’t get me wrong, the pizza was very good. $34 for an eight slice pizza was tough to stomach though. I know there’s a lot of money on this island, but for a regular Joe, that’s steep. Especially when this place is basically take out only. There is one table available to sit at in the little breezeway, but we were far more comfortable just taking it back and eating it in our hotel lobby. I also requested the largest pizza which is apparently 12 slices, but he was pretty adamant about talking me down to the 8 slice pizza which I thought was strange. He said I could always come back if I wanted more (obviously this would mean buying yet another highly-priced pizza). If you don’t mind paying a lot for a good pizza, I recommend this place. I personally will try something else next time though.

4 /5 Jason R.: The owner is Vinny and an authentic New Yorker! Pizza by the slice was thin crust and very delicious but only wish they were bigger. Only one table to sit at so I wish there was more places to sit. Service was good and pizza came out popping hot. I would recommend this place for pizza lovers.

4 /5 Aplih A: When visiting the islands, tried the take-out pizza from this spot, and overall, it was a good experience. The NY-style slices and whole pizza are primary on the menu with a few other options of garlic bread, pasta, etc. Ordered chicken and veggie toppings - it was delicious crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor. The taste definitely makes up for the longer wait time, though it is a bit on the pricier side. One downside was the customer service, which came across with a bit of attitude. Despite that, the quality of the pizza makes it worth a visit.

1 /5 Talia Winner: Looks like pizza but doesn’t taste like pizza. The crust is like cardboard, there is no flavor whatsoever. Overpriced when you consider flavor to cost ratio. I will not go back there.

5 /5 Michael: We went there 3 months ago (Jan, 2025). The vegan pizza was great. It was huge and very beautiful when we opened the box. We ordered the biggest size. The vegan cheese was melty and not glue like (such as Daiya cheese). The owner couldnt remember the brand of vegan cheese they used, but it tasted very good and very filling. We had plenty of leftovers. At that time there was only takeout available, no seating. There was only one person working so the wait was a bit long, we just went explore the town more and came back to pick it up.