washington Date: 09-18-2025

Top 10 Rated Jeweler in Olympia, WA (part 2)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Olympia Rare Coins2921 Pacific Ave SE, Olympia, WA 98501
2Olympia Jewelry Gold & Silver Coins415 Sleater Kinney Rd SE, Olympia, WA 98503
3Super Silver Olympia505 Capitol Way S, Olympia, WA 98501
4JCPenney625 Black Lake Blvd SW, Olympia, WA 98502
5Spicy Pepper Permanent Jewelry3025 Limited Ln NW, Olympia, WA 98502
6Diamond Creations625 Black Lake Blvd SW, Olympia, WA 98502
7Ziva Shayna Design Company: Handcrafted Copper Jewelry Designs1003 Fir St NE, Olympia, WA 98506
8Jewelry By Marrial3215 Eastland Cir SE, Olympia, WA 98501
9Fair Portia116 5th Ave SE j, Olympia, WA 98501
10Electra Crafts501 Franz Anderson Rd SE, Olympia, WA 98501

1.Olympia Rare Coins

Address: 2921 Pacific Ave SE, Olympia, WA 98501

(162) user ratings total:

Janet Ryan Went in today for the first time after shopping around for the best price of gold and the owner Welby gave me the best price, very kind of him. He was very personable and it was a very easy transaction. I was extremely pleased with the price and the way he treats his costumers. Will share my experience to friends and families. Thank you!
5 /5

2.Olympia Jewelry Gold & Silver Coins

Address: 415 Sleater Kinney Rd SE, Olympia, WA 98503

(157) user ratings total:

Sierra Leckenby Daniel was so great and down to earth. He was very patient and helpful. Its always a breath of fresh air to not feel rushed. I definitely recommend his expertise and his knowledge on all jewelry! Hes a very kind man and he brightened my day for sure! He was also very fair and honest! Thank you!
5 /5

3.Super Silver Olympia

Address: 505 Capitol Way S, Olympia, WA 98501

(129) user ratings total:

The Barbos We LOVE Super Silver! The jewelry is gorgeous and the prices are fantastic. My family has been shopping with them for years. I always stop in for my birthday every year and pick out something special. The people are amazing! So friendly and always helpful.
5 /5

4.JCPenney

Address: 625 Black Lake Blvd SW, Olympia, WA 98502

(1262) user ratings total:

Richard Myer My Wife called in a curbside order for me to pick up, I got the confirmation that it was ready. Went to the store try to do curbside, couldn’t get it to work tried calling the store nobody you can talk to called and connected with the department. Explain to the people that I was unable to connect with anybody. She said she was going to contact someone and my order would be out shortly 45 minutes later still nothing. I called her back, but no one answered. Tried the operator. No one available. Eventually a lady came out with the wrong package and acted like I was putting her out.. Then she went back into store and came out with the correct package and said the problem was it was never ordered curbside. I said that’s funny because I have the confirmation for the curbside order and that it is ready. What an outfit, pretty easy to see why they’re closing lots of their stores. I definitely won’t be back.
1 /5

5.Spicy Pepper Permanent Jewelry

Address: 3025 Limited Ln NW, Olympia, WA 98502

6.Diamond Creations

Address: 625 Black Lake Blvd SW, Olympia, WA 98502

(1) user ratings total:

Chrystal Grover I am very displeased with the so called "Service" and this company in general. First off, I had a layaway for a engagement ring for my fiance. About a week later i found the SAME ring, same CUT COLOR MATERIAL COMPANY.. etc on amazon for THIRTY FIVE DOLLARS. This ring was a carbine tungsten ring. The ring in diamond creations that i had on layaway was almost FOUR HUNDRED DOLLARS. Very displeased i went in to the capital mall store. Since it was only a few days after the lay away deadline they promised a full refund with a personal call from the manager with an apology.. HA that never happened. I then went in a second time where i was profusely apologized to and was told i could pick up my refund after work the next day while the manager was in, so far TWO employees had promised me a refund and apology. I then went into the store and instead of an apology i talked to a "manager" who just bad mouthed her employees basically saying that she is sorry none of them know what they are doing and will talk to the OWNER of the store and make sure this was taken care of. Then........ THE STORE CLOSED DOWN. EVERY time i had been promised I had two or three people with me as a witness. LIKE THAT MATTERED. like it mattered you could buy the SAME ring on amazon for 35 dollars!!!!!!! Then i was called by the Tacoma store manager because that store is still in business. It wasnt his fault the "Olympia" store had messed up and would only offer "store credit" as it I wanted that, and like it mattered that i had been promised otherwise!!! So i drive all the way from Olympia and Tacoma thinking i Will make the best of the situation. HA. I told him I was very displeased and had my fiance with me to pick out something with that store credit.. Even though i was the only one in the store at the time I was told to please wait, so he could apparently help more important (Im guessing richer looking) customers. He then tryed to pressure me into doing another layaway for a piece of art i was fond with, which since he was ignoring me, i had time to look up on-line and find the EXACT SAME numbered signed, etc for about 75% less on the price. Still we forced a smile and to quickly get out said i wish to get my mother a gift, no more than the 100$ i had in the layaway, he agreed to help, i told him what i was looking for, then when asked the pricing of all the items he had shown me they were all about 100$ more and like i would EVER give them more money. He then got EXTREMELY snotty and tells me there is apparently NOTHING in the WHOLE store that is 100$ or less.... REALLY?? There sure was PLENTY at the Olympia store. Honestly this is the WORST experience i have ever had with any sort of store, layaway etc. It is no wonder the Olympia store had closed down, and i will continue to let every one know at the medical facility surgical hospital i work at and patients to NEVER go there. I wont be coming back. I would rather sell the gift card for HALF the price or just never use it before i go back and deal with the snotty Tacoma manager or anyone else i had to deal with. Worst service we have ever received by any company hands down. And people think there cell phone company is bad. I would rather pay triple the price to shop at a different jewelry store than go back here. Do your research before purchase your 400$ item is probably only 35$ on amazon as well.
1 /5

7.Ziva Shayna Design Company: Handcrafted Copper Jewelry Designs

Address: 1003 Fir St NE, Olympia, WA 98506

8.Jewelry By Marrial

Address: 3215 Eastland Cir SE, Olympia, WA 98501

9.Fair Portia

Address: 116 5th Ave SE j, Olympia, WA 98501

10.Electra Crafts

Address: 501 Franz Anderson Rd SE, Olympia, WA 98501