Casa Mia Italian Restaurant - Puyallup (WA)

5 /5 John Navarro: Casa Mia is an amazing Pizza & Pasta place to dine in or take out. Weve tried both door dash and dine-in experience and the quality and service is amazing! The customer service is 5 star. Ive ordered the lasagna, spaghetti and Meatballs, and the chicken Alfredo, all turned out delicious and satisfying. We ordered a Calzone to-go and the chief and staff kept me aware that it was ready whenever your ready, also kept my drink topped off as well! The waiter was an amazing guy as well, gave me a discount and also was very generous and great to chat with. The place was overall quiet and relaxing when we went (Wife & Myself). The pasta was cooked to perfection and every pasta dish that was served came out hot and worth every bite, prices are fair for pasta dishes and the portions are just right. If your looking for some good delicious pasta give Casa Mia a try, its worth very penny!

5 /5 Tobi LeMond: Sunday special, All You Can Eat for $12.99. The staff was attentive, friendly and the food and drinks delivered timely. Spegghetti was great! Absolutely love the buttered rolls!

4 /5 S: The waitress was an amazing lady. Food was pretty good!!!!

5 /5 Sheila: Dinner at Casa Mia in downtown Puyallup tonight with family. I have been wanting to eat at this Italian restaurant for awhile now. The atmosphere was cozy and the service was great. The food was delicious and good size portions. Will definitely visit again!

5 /5 Janet Rhodes Gregory: The service was phenomenal. I wish I got the waitress name, but we were there 10/28/2025 about 5pm. She was helpful, fast, & very accommodating. Then the food came. It was fresh, hot, & delicious. The chef was also very on point, handling orders immediately, with expertise. Their rolls came directly out of the oven, with freshly grated parmesan on top. Even the soup was clearly house made, with visible seasonings. Casa Mia has new loyal customers. No more Olive Garden for us!