Tobys Tavern - Coupeville (WA)

5 /5 Erin sorensen: My Bestie and I went to Toby’s for lunch on Saturday. We got the last 2 seats available.Our server was named Sue and she was awesome! Very informative and fast .Our food was amazing, I can’t wait to go back! The clam chowder was the BEST I ever had! The energy of the place was also great. We can’t wait to come back! Thank you Sue for your excellent service and food

5 /5 Lisa Pottruff: The staff at Tobys is really great! They are super friendly and know what they are doing! We loved our service. The smoked salmon chowder was delicious!!! I enjoyed the Tobys Red Ale as well. The Salmon and Chips had so much batter, it wasnt as good as it could have been. This is a cozy little place with beautiful views. If we lived nearby, we would come here often.

3 /5 Indiana Lanzas: My best friend and I came here for lunch. It was packed and we had to wait for the table. To me this just meant the food was going to be great. The wait for the table was not as bad as we had anticipated. To drink, I had a Stella beer. You cannot go wrong with a cold beer. To eat, I tried the seafood chowder. It was tasty and it had a little bit of everything. As an entree, I had the hot honey cod bites, which was delicious. The hot honey elevated the taste of the cod. My best friend had the fish chips and she enjoyed it. When we were done eating, it took us a bit to get the server’s attention to ask for the check but we understood why as it was full. The staff was nonstop. This was a nice casual tavern to have lunch in.

3 /5 Sarah Justice: Our service was good. Our waiter brought us out a piece of hot brownie dessert just because before we ate. There were two people waiting on us and someone else brought out our food. Our portions were a good size. My hamburger was burnt on the outside. My boyfriend got fish and chips. The coleslaw was good. It’s good for just bar food if that’s what you’re looking for. I’d say go once try it yourself. I will say it was a little uncomfortable being 2 people sitting at a booth for 6 or more.

4 /5 Justin Brummage: A great tavern featuring local pub-style dishes. The atmosphere truly felt authentic and local, and the prices were reasonable given the area. However, the service was a bit inconsistent. We received a warm welcome and prompt attention at first, but then it seemed to lose steam. Our waiter was friendly but prioritize some tables much more than others, which left us and seemingly the other ignored tables feeling overlooked. Despite the ups and downs, it’s still a great place worth checking out; it just feels like they could benefit from a few more staff members to enhance the overall experience of guests.